Is Ōtautahi/Christchurch returning to the delta it once was?

In February 2023, Cyclone Gabrielle dumped up to 500 millimetres of rain on the North of New Zealand, with devastating effects. Frank Film set out to investigate what would happen if a similar amount of rain fell on Ōtautahi Christchurch.

On a rainy autumn day, Professor Matthew Wilson and Doctor John Reid trudge through Christchurch’s sodden Residential Red Zone.

Less than 30 millimetres of rain has fallen on the city in the past 24 hours, yet there are already clear signs of flooding: the Avon has swelled significantly and, in the city centre, cars are splashing through the surface water flooding.

Professor Wilson, director of the Geospatial Research Institute Toi Hangarau, studies the ponding in the Red Zone. “You can imagine that, if something like Gabrielle happened in Christchurch – with 400 to 500 millimetres of rainfall – we’d be really swimming through the water at the moment,” he says.

This leads the Frank Film team to bigger questions: how well-prepared is Ōtautahi Christchurch for floods? Does the natural lie of the land affect our flood risk? What did this area look like in the past, and what does the future hold for us?

Dr. Reid (Ngāti Pikiao, Tainui, Tauiwi), a senior research fellow at the Ngāi Tahu Centre, explains that, before European colonisation, Ngāi Tūāhuriri lived on an Ōtautahi that was very different to the Christchurch we know today.

Ōtautahi Christchurch is naturally a delta: a wetland that forms as rivers drain into another body of water, such as an ocean.

According to Dr. Reid, if you want to get an idea of what much of Ōtautahi looked like before European colonisation, you should take a walk through the verdant Travis Wetlands.

“Ōtautahi was an area flourishing with life: high in mauri,” he says. Back then, it was possible to travel in a mōkihi (a canoe woven from flax) all the way from Kaiapoi to Taumutu. “And the wisdom of how best to live on the delta is still held by Ngāi Tūāhuriri today.”

But when Pakēha chose to build Christchurch on the delta in the 19th century, they decided to “move the water off the land as fast as possible,” says Prof. Wilson. In a mammoth undertaking, the swampy delta was drained by European settlers to clear the way for the city’s development.

Over the decades since, Christchurch has been subject to many flooding events. The city’s foundation on wetland has made it vulnerable to flooding from its inception – and we remain vulnerable today.
Prof. Wilson believes that we are, in many ways, well-protected. We’re fortunate, he points out, to have the Southern Alps on the west, which suck in much of the rainfall from potentially dangerous weather systems.

But such a system falling on the east of the divide would cause the Waimakariri to rise. “It’s a beautiful river, but dangerous in many ways.” He cites a photograph of a major 1868 flood caused by the Waimakariri breaching its banks.

Fortunately, a sophisticated double-stopbank system now guards us from most such breaches. The Waimakariri stopbanks were initially built in the 1930s, and have since been continually improved and reinforced by Environment Canterbury, with secondary stopbanks completed in 2021.

The experts are confident that the city has a comprehensive flood management plan. In Wigram, for example, Ngāi Tahu and the Christchurch City Council have built several large basins and swales, which catch rainwater and prevent floods.

So far, so good. So – can we relax?

Not quite. Dr. Reid and Prof. Wilson believe that, despite so many protective measures, there remains cause for concern.

Our deltaic history holds the key to our future.

Climate change is causing sea levels to rise. “As the sea level rises, so, too, the wetlands return,” says Dr. Reid. “Current projections show that about 35% of Christchurch will be inundated by 2100.”

That is: in eighty years’ time, it is predicted that about a third of Ōtautahi Christchurch will be vulnerable to regular flooding. Low-lying areas of the city – areas which used to be wetlands – are most at risk.

The inevitable sea level rise will cause the water table of these areas to rise. “In that situation, when it rains heavily… because the water table is so high, it doesn’t have anywhere to go,” Prof. Wilson says. “It causes much more flooding, as the ground can’t absorb it any more.”

“The delta is coming back,” says Dr. Reid. “What do we do, knowing that’s going to happen?”

Credits

Producer/Director/Cameraman/Interviewer: Gerard Smyth
Editor: Oliver Dawe
Researcher/Writer: Nicole Phillipson
Production Manager: Jo Ffitch
Post-Production Coordinator/Graphics: Andy Johnson
Sound Design/Mix: Chris Sinclair
Second Camera/Drone: Richard Hansen

Attributions

Christchurch City Libraries;
- File Reference: CCL-StarP-01759A
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 9, IMG0037
- File Reference: CCLKPCD1 - IMG0026
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 7, IMG0006
- File Reference: CCL-KPCD1-IMG0025
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 5, IMG0066
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 6, IMG0025
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 16, IMG0080
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 9, IMG0036
- File Reference: CCL-DW-126981
- File Reference: CCL PhotoCD 14 IMG0090
- UUID: 778cf177-d4fd-45c4-81b8-bedb1d9eb4ed

Alexander Turnbull Library;
- Edward Seager Album, Reference: 1/2-022720-F, Photograph by Alfred Charles Barker
- Boys fishing in the Avon River, Christchurch. Haynes, W (Mrs), fl 1955 :Photograph album of photographs taken by C Edwards. Ref: PA1-f-020-12-3

Stuff Ltd;
- Flooded Emmett Street (2022), photographer Chris Skelton
- Hoon Hay family in floodwaters (2022), photographer Chris Skelton
- Civil defense by flooded Heathcote I & II (2017), photographer Joseph Johnson
- Emergency responders rescue Chch residents (2019), photographer Joseph Johnson
- Man wading through flooded Beckenham street (2022), photographer Peter Meecham
- Emmett St resident in floodwater (2022), photographer Chris Skelton

Star Media;
Emily Harper - Christchurch from near the Gloucester Street Bridge, Collection of Christchurch Art Gallery Te Puna o Waiwhetū; gift of the Acland family, 20

Charles Haubroe - Watercolour of the Horotueka/Cam River, Canterbury Museum, reference: 1951.15.5

Three pictures of the Waimakariri River provided by Environment Canterbury